Brick house entrance with ivory columns, charcoal door, blue-gray stone steps and a burgundy oakleaf hydrangea.

The Credit Math That Decides Where Bernardsville's New Homes Go

October 22, 2026

Bernardsville's state-mandated affordable housing obligation for 2025 to 2035 is 113 homes. Twenty-nine of those credits come from condominiums that were finished in the 1990s. The 30-year price controls on affordable units at Pine Ridge and Rolling Ridge are expiring, and the borough proposes paying $20,000 to each owner who agrees to keep their unit affordable. That makes extending those controls the second-largest piece of the plan.

The rest of the plan follows a similar logic. New Jersey's affordable housing rules give extra credit to certain kinds of sites, and in Bernardsville those sites are the blocks near the train station and a former quarry strip off Bernards Avenue.

The Condo Units at the Center of the Plan

The borough's Fourth Round mediation agreement describes two developments from the 1990s. Pine Ridge has 26 affordable for-sale units, built mostly in 1995 and 1996, with controls expiring in 2025 and 2026. Rolling Ridge, which the borough's documents also call Rolling Hills at Bernardsville, has 15 affordable for-sale units completed between 1995 and 1998, with controls expiring between 2025 and 2028. Three units in each development were already extended during the Third Round.

In total, 35 units can be extended. The borough is counting on 29 and will go up to 35 if it has the money and owners agree. According to the agreement, 29 owners have expressed interest.

How the Bonus Credits Shape the Map

Site Affordable units Bonus credits Total credits
Bernards Avenue redevelopment, family rental 36 18 54
Pine Ridge / Rolling Ridge extensions 29 0 29
Clarus Redevelopment Area, age-restricted rental 19 6 25
65 Claremont Road, family rental 6 0 6
Total 90 24 114

Under the amended state Fair Housing Act, two kinds of sites earn an extra half credit per affordable unit: redeveloped former commercial land, and sites within half a mile of a New Jersey Transit station. The Bernards Avenue site qualifies as former commercial land. The Clarus site at Church Street and Morristown Road sits about 0.2 miles from Bernardsville Station. The rules cap bonus credits at 25 percent of the obligation, which works out to 28 here. Bernardsville's plan uses 24 of them.

Another cap shapes the Clarus site. Age-restricted units can make up no more than 30 percent of the obligation, or 25 credits. Clarus is the only age-restricted site in the plan, and its 19 units plus 6 bonus credits come to exactly 25.

These sites also bring market-rate homes with them. The borough built only affordable housing in earlier rounds. In this round, developers can add market-rate units to help pay for the affordable ones, the Bernardsville News reported. The settlement zoning in Ordinance 2041 allows:

  • up to 180 units on Bernards Avenue, at least 36 of them affordable
  • about 96 units at the Clarus site, at least 19 of them affordable
  • up to 28 units at 65 Claremont Road, with a 20 percent affordable set-aside

At Clarus, that's about 48 units per acre on roughly two acres.

Why the Old Quarry Site Was Dropped

The borough's first Fourth Round plan, which the Council approved in June 2025, relied partly on a Quarry Site Affordable Housing Overlay District. That site covered 69 acres off Route 202, outside the borough's sewer service area. Bernardsville had received 28 credits for it in the Third Round and wanted 23 more. In August 2025, Fair Share Housing Center and other parties challenged the plan, arguing among other things that the quarry site was not realistic. The settlement removed it, according to the Bernardsville News.

With the quarry gone, the borough needed sites with sewer service, and two of the three replacement sites, Bernards Avenue and Clarus, also earn bonus credits. The total planned across the three new-construction sites rose from 247 homes in the 2025 plan to 304 under the settlement. Ordinance 2041 states that Judge William G. Mennen approved the settlement on January 16, 2026. On March 9, the Council adopted Ordinances 2041 and 2043 to put it in place.

Mayor Mary Jane Canose made a point about timing in a message the Bernardsville News quoted:

"Identifying sites in the Fair Share Plan does not mean development is automatic. Any proposed project still must go through the borough's approval process and comply with site plan or redevelopment requirements, as well as public hearings."

What the July Hearing Raised About Each Site

The two larger sites, Clarus and Bernards Avenue, went to the Planning Board on July 23 as proposed non-condemnation redevelopment areas.

The Clarus area covers 10 and 8 Church Street, 30 and 22 Morristown Road, and part of 1-7 Anderson Hill Road. The businesses there include J. Skin by Design, Discovery Antiques & Jewelry and a Columbia Bank branch. At the hearing, the Bernardsville News reported, most public comment was about the library. The study area includes the library's Church Street entrance and a borough parking area, where the paper counted 23 spaces. Library Director Mary Fran Daley said the library had more than 94,000 visits last year and is on track to pass 100,000 this year. Chairman Graham said the borough intends to keep the Church Street access whatever is built there. Board member Andrew Mallia called the library "a jewel to this town." The board recommended the designation 7 to 0.

The Bernards Avenue site was part of the Ferrante Quarry, which operated from 1931 to 1985. Today its lots are used by landscaping and construction businesses. The borough's 2000 and 2017 master plan reexaminations both recommended rezoning the area for residential use. Graham said he had asked the Council, without success, to route some traffic to Mine Avenue so that it would not all use Bernards Avenue. He cast the only vote against the recommendation, which passed 6 to 1.

Library parking near Clarus and traffic on Bernards Avenue remain open questions for the Council and for any detailed site plans.

Where Things Stand This Fall

The Council's September 28 agenda listed Resolution 26-214, which would designate the Clarus area, and Resolution 26-215, which would designate the Danbro site on Bernards Avenue. Designation would come before any construction. The next steps are a redevelopment plan and a named redeveloper. As of mid-October, the borough's posted 2026 ordinances don't include a redevelopment plan for either site.

The Third Round projects are further along but not finished. The borough paid for 60 rentals, all affordable: 26 at 149 Mine Brook Road, 22 at 63 Bernards Avenue and 12 on Mount Airy Road, on the former Amerman parking lot. The borough's affordable housing page quotes the developer expecting to deliver them in fall 2026. An October 2026 Somerset Hills School District demographic study still lists all three as under construction, with timing given as 2026 to 2027.

Downtown development and housing are also issues in the November 3 Borough Council race. The Bernardsville News covered both the Republican candidates and the Democratic candidates. Democratic candidate Jeffrey Roos called downtown redevelopment a "balancing act," the paper reported.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does the plan add housing to Bernardsville's estate sections? No. All three new-construction sites are on Bernards Avenue, at Church Street and Morristown Road, or at 65 Claremont Road. The fourth part of the plan extends controls on existing condos.

How many affordable homes has Bernardsville been required to provide in total? The borough's FAQ puts the total across all four rounds at 414, the Bernardsville News reported. The Third Round obligation alone was 215.

Where can I read the settlement terms? The mediation agreement and the Fourth Round documents are posted on the borough's affordable housing page.

If you're weighing a move within Bernardsville as these sites take shape, Karen Tyrell can walk through how a nearby redevelopment site may affect pricing. A free home valuation is a good place to start.

Work With Karen

Get assistance in determining current property value, crafting a competitive offer, writing and negotiating a contract, and much more. Contact me today.