November 12, 2026
Where do you buy milk, a rotisserie chicken and a week of produce in Bernards Township now? Since the end of October, the answer depends on how big the trip is. For a quick stop, there is still a grocery store in town, plus a small cluster of food shops a few blocks from the Lyons Mall. For a full supermarket cart, you now have to drive to a neighboring town.
The Stop & Shop at 553 South Finley Avenue closed permanently at 6 p.m. on Thursday, October 29. The Bernardsville News at newjerseyhills.com reported that by closing time much of the stock had been sold off and long stretches of shelves were empty. The Stop & Shop sign was gone from the building the next morning. The same paper said the closing left the township without a supermarket for the first time in 55 years.
The closing was announced in July. TAPinto Basking Ridge reported that the company tied the decision to a financial review and the end of its lease. Employees were offered transfers to Stop & Shop stores in Berkeley Heights, Madison and Watchung.
The big space at the center of the mall is expected to sell food again. Mayor Ana Duarte McCarthy told the Bernardsville News that after the Township Committee meeting on October 27, she contacted the mall owner. She was told a food retailer would take the space but couldn't be named yet because the lease was still being negotiated. "We hope that indeed comes to be," the mayor said. Until a new tenant opens, the weekly grocery run here works differently, starting with one store.
When the closing was first announced, Patch noted that Green's Natural Foods would be the grocery store left in town, with ShopRite of Bernardsville close by. Patch's July story also called the Lyons Mall store one of only two supermarkets in Basking Ridge.
Green's Natural Foods is at 25 Mountainview Boulevard, and the phone number is 908-495-1600. The store opened in December 2012 as Dean's Natural Food Market. Its opening profile listed certified-organic produce, salad, grain and juice bars, bulk foods, prepared foods, deli meats and chicken, and natural household products. Green's now describes itself as a natural and organic grocery and advertises produce, lunch, juices and smoothies. The township's 2026 food inspection list shows it passed a satisfactory inspection on April 6, 2026.
So the township has no conventional supermarket, but it does have a grocery store. Green's is a specialty grocer built around organic and prepared food. For produce, a lunch counter and pantry basics, you can still shop without leaving town.
The rest of what's left in town is small and specialized, and much of it sits along South Maple Avenue and the side streets near the Lyons Mall:
The Lyons Mall itself has another food business on the way. The Dunkin' at 450 South Finley Avenue closed at the end of March. TAPinto reported in August that Gabe's Bagels would take over the space. The owner, Gabe Gebril, told The Crimson, the Bernards High School student paper, that the chain has been around since 2004. It sells hand-rolled, New York-style bagels along with sandwiches, wraps, soups and salads. A second new shop is planned at 23 Mine Brook Road in Bernardsville, next to Tsuki.
All of these shops are good for a coffee, a lunch order, a catering tray or a gift box. None of them sells a full week of groceries for a household, so that trip now leads out of the township.
The closest full-service supermarkets are spread across five nearby towns. Store pages listed these addresses and hours in early November 2026; holiday hours may differ, so check the store's page before a late-evening trip.
| Store | Address | Posted hours | Ordering options |
|---|---|---|---|
| ShopRite of Bernardsville | 93 Morristown Road, Bernardsville | Daily, 7 a.m. to 9 p.m. | In store, pickup, delivery |
| ShopRite of Stirling | 1153 Valley Road, Stirling | Mon to Sat, 7 a.m. to 10 p.m.; Sun, 7 a.m. to 9 p.m. | In store, pickup, delivery |
| Kings Food Markets | 450 Hills Drive, Bedminster | Daily, 7 a.m. to 10 p.m. | In store |
| Trader Joe's | 315 Promenade Boulevard, Bridgewater | Daily, 9 a.m. to 9 p.m. | In store |
| Whole Foods Market, Bridgewater store | 319 Chimney Rock Road, Bound Brook | Daily, 8 a.m. to 9 p.m. | In store |
The Bernardsville News described ShopRite on Route 202 in Bernardsville as the only competing supermarket within several miles. Both ShopRite stores list pickup and delivery. With either one, the weekly order can be placed online, so the longer drive is optional.
Whole Foods calls its store "Bridgewater," but the street address is in Bound Brook, which matters when you type it into a GPS. Kings in Bedminster has the latest weeknight closing time on the list, along with the Stirling ShopRite on Monday through Saturday.
Two seasonal markets, one ending this month and one starting next month, fill some of the gap.
The Bernardsville Farmers' Market runs Saturdays from 9 a.m. to 1 p.m. through November 21. That leaves two Saturdays this season, November 14 and November 21. The market has brought local farmers, bakers, makers and growers together for more than 30 years, and its site posts the vendors expected each week.
After that, the nearest regular market moves to Morristown. Grow It Green Morristown holds its winter market on Sundays from 9:30 a.m. to 1 p.m., December through April. It sets up in the Convent Station train station parking lot at 11 Convent Road.
The holidays arrive with 553 South Finley Avenue dark and the sign gone, and the mayor has been told the next tenant will be a food retailer. Lyons Mall owner Barbara Mackes told the Bernardsville News when the closing was announced that an announcement would be forthcoming. Back in July, the landlord said a new tenant was preparing plans and specifications for the township to review.
Changes like this one at Lyons Mall shape daily life in Basking Ridge in ways a listing description never shows. If you've lived here a long time and are thinking about what comes next, I'm glad to talk it through, including what your home is worth today. Karen Tyrell offers a free home valuation, with no pressure and plenty of local context.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
Get assistance in determining current property value, crafting a competitive offer, writing and negotiating a contract, and much more. Contact me today.